Why a stress free dog is not necessarily a happy dog - according to science


Hey Reader,

I want to tell you something about happiness. This is no longer a vague concept but something science can now describe in concrete terms and that has direct implications for the way you work with dogs.

Research shows that happiness in dogs comes down to what scientists call the affective balance: the ratio of positive to negative experiences over time. The animal that feels good most often has the balance tipping in the right direction. That might sound straightforward, but there is a little nuance here (isn’t there always?).

That balance is built from short-term emotions.

Every fear response, every frustration, every moment of genuine curiosity or relaxed connection is fleeting, but it doesn't simply disappear. Short-term emotions accumulate and colour a dog's mood across the hours that follow.

Those moods, day after day and week after week, are what shape the affective balance. A dog that regularly experiences small moments of anxiety or stress, even when they never escalate and even when he seems calm in between, gradually builds a more negative balance than you might expect.

And the reverse is equally true: a dog that regularly experiences genuine positive emotions, curiosity, playfulness, a sense of control over his environment, connection with his person, builds a balance that makes him genuinely more resilient when things do go wrong.

Short-term emotions are not small or insignificant. They are the building blocks of happiness.

And this is exactly what I find so fascinating about how the dog's brain works. The brain is constantly predicting what is about to happen, based on previous experience, and then adjusting those predictions in response to what actually occurs.

Those internal calculations determine whether a situation gets labelled as safe or as threatening, they shape the emotion that follows, and that emotion shapes the behaviour. When you understand how that process works β€” how a short-term emotion arises, how it ripples into mood, and how moods influence the affective balance β€” you start looking at the dogs you work with in a fundamentally different way. You no longer see only the behaviour. You see the pattern underneath it.

And that pattern is exactly where real behavioural change begins.

That is why I am giving a live session soon: How Emotions Drive Problem Behaviour in Dogs.

We will go into how emotions arise in the brain, how the brain functions as a prediction machine, and how short-term emotions integrate into moods that ultimately determine the affective balance. Including what that means for dogs who get stuck in anxious, reactive or shut-down behaviour. This is not a repeat of what you already know about stress signals. This is the layer beneath them.

You will come away with a clear neurobiological framework for how emotions arise and carry forward, an understanding of why standard training approaches sometimes fall short with emotion-driven behaviour, and a way of explaining all of this to your clients β€” not from intuition, but from grounded, evidence-based knowledge. You will also receive the Emotions in Dogs poster as a PDF bonus, a visual overview you can use directly in client conversations.

The session is live online on 26th of March, ad includes access to the recording.

πŸ‘‰ <<< Register here >>>>​

If you have been working from a welfare perspective for a while but find yourself not always getting to the root of the problem, this session is for you.

Not because you are doing something wrong, but because there is a layer that most training programmes simply never cover.

See you then,

Dr. Else 🧠

Amazing Animal Minds

P.S. Can't make it live? No problem at all. You will receive the recording and the bonus poster either way, and you can work through everything at your own pace whenever it suits you.

Best,

Dr. Else

Hi, I'm Else, specialist in dog behaviour and welfare.

Dr. Else Verbeek is a highly skilled and compassionate dog behaviorist who is dedicated to helping dogs overcome fear and anxiety. With a strong foundation in evidence-based practices, she utilizes her scientific expertise to create effective strategies for addressing behavioral issues in dogs.With over 15 years of experience in the field, Else has honed her skills in understanding and modifying canine behavior. Her background as a scientist specializing in behavior, emotions, and stress physiology allows her to bring a unique perspective to her work with dogs. Else's approach is grounded in the latest research, ensuring that her interventions are based on solid scientific evidence. She recognizes that every dog is an individual with unique needs, and she tailors her methods to suit each dog's specific circumstances. In addition to her work with individual dogs, Else is also passionate about education and knowledge-sharing. She regularly teaches problem behavior courses to dog professionals, empowering them with the tools and knowledge to better understand and address canine behavioral issues. Else is equally dedicated to helping dog owners navigate their pets' problem behaviors. Through her compassionate and patient guidance, she assists owners in understanding the underlying causes of their dogs' issues and provides practical strategies to improve their pets' behavior and quality of life. With her extensive experience, scientific background, and commitment to evidence-based practices, Else stands out as a respected and trusted authority in the field of dog behavior. Her unwavering dedication to improving the lives of dogs and their owners has made her a sought-after expert in the industry. Do you want to understand your dog's behaviour, solve unwanted behaviours and improve your relationship with your dog? Sign up to my newsletter now!

Read more from Hi, I'm Else, specialist in dog behaviour and welfare.

Hi Reader, Counterconditioning is een van de meest aanbevolen technieken om ongewenst gedrag te veranderen. Je gebruikt het vast dagelijks. En toch is er verrassend weinig onderzoek naar gedaan. In 2024 publiceerden Shnookal et al. een systematische review van alle beschikbare studies die counterconditioning bij gezelschapshonden hebben getest. Ze vonden in totaal 14 studies (12 peer-reviewed papers en 2 proefschriften), wat eigenlijk best wel weinig is voor een techniek die we constant...

Hi Reader, Counterconditioning is one of the most frequently recommended techniques in dog behaviour modification, and most of us use it (or some version of it) almost daily. So when a systematic review on counterconditioning in dogs came out in 2024, I was very cursious. Some of the findings were quite uncomfortable, in a useful way. The authors (Shnookal, Tepper, Howell and Bennett) looked at every available study testing counterconditioning in companion dogs. They found 14 studies in...

Hoi Reader, Er is net een nieuw onderzoek uitgekomen waarbij ze hebben gekeken of lavendelolie kan helpen om stress te verminderen bij de dierenarts. Benieuwd naar de resultaten? Ik heb er een instagram carousel over gemaakt: Bekijk de carousel hier Fijne zondag! Groet,, Dr. Else